May 272010

Cardinal Eugène Tisserant, 1956

Pius XII (#261) is said to have refused French Cardinal Eugène Tisserant [1884-1972] permission to leave the Vatican at the outbreak of WW II when Cardinal Tisserant expressed his desire to return to France and serve in the French army.

Tisserant, in a similar fashion to Angelo Giuseppe Roncalli [future John XXIII (#262)], served as an French army intelligence officer during WW I, though he had been ordained a priest in 1907. [Angello Roncalli, ordained in 1904, was drafted into the Royal Italian Army as a sergeant, serving in initially in the medical corps as a stretcher-bearer before being made a chaplain. Pius XII did not serve in WW I since he was a relatively senior curial official by then.]

I was doing some research into cardinal bishops yesterday when I came across this statement of Pius XII’s alleged reluctance to let Cardinal Tisserant go back to France.

At face value one could immediately dismiss this as being one of brotherly love between humans, with the pope wanting to keep another human (very gifted at that) away from the dangers of war. But, I got to thinking.

There could have been another reason. Having a relatively senior cardinal, who had held curial office, serving in the French army could have had a negative impact on the German forces – nearly half of whom were devout Catholics! This was one of Hitler’s biggest fears. The potential of the Catholic church to influence his troops. In reality this never came to pass.

But, what would have been the case IF Cardinal Tisserant left the Vatican and started working for the French army?

It is something to think about – my motto in life being ‘Think Free, Or Die.’

Pius XII Definitely Had German Connections
Pius XII’s apparent inaction during WW II has by now been widely discussed and debated, particularly so after John Cornwell’s ‘not-as-detailed-as-I-would-have-liked’ Hitler’s Pope book of 1999. I have no desire to rehash those topics.

From my perspective, as a hopefully objective, with really no axe to grind papal historian, I do, however, invariably come across four hard-and-fast, irrefutable, facts about Pius XII’s relationship with Germany that always give me pause. These are:

  1. He was a nuncio to Bavaria (essentially ‘German Empire’) and then Germany as of 1917 to 1930 – a total of 29 years.
  2. The German Sister (later Mother) Pascalina Lehnert, his ‘housekeeper’ for 41 uninterrupted years, in Germany and at the Vatican, was a very close and trusted confidant despite what most would have to contend was a rather incongruous relationship.
  3. Next to Pascalina Lehnert, the Pius’s two closest confidants were both German, the Jesuit Robert Leiber and Ludwig Kass. Around 1936 Kass, exiled from Germany, took residence in the Vatican. During Pius’s papacy Leiber, Kass and Lehnert constantly revolved around the pope, like Mercury, Venus and Earth around the Sun. < Enough said. >
  4. Pius XII’s greatest achievement prior to becoming pope was the concordat that he executed with Germany, with Hitler’s support, when he was the Secretary of State.

Since this posting is mainly about the French Cardinal Tisserant, I will let him have the last word about this pope. Prior to the 1939 conclave that would elect him Pope Pius XII, Cardinal Tisserant talking to the French ambassador to the Holy See had this to say about the soon to be pope: ‘indecisive, hesitant, a man more designed to obey orders than to give them.’
< Some do say, in his defense, that this was the real reason for his lack of overt leadership during the War. >

Eugène Tisserant Was Special
Between 1900 to 1961 Eugène Tisserant was to be the only non-Italian Cardinal Bishop.

He would be the Dean of the College of Cardinals from 1951 to his death in 1972. He was an acknowledged scholar, who had studied in Jerusalem, who was fluent in many languages, including Arabic, Hebrew, Russian, Assyrian, Persian etc. He became associated with the Vatican Library as of 1919 and would eventually be the Librarian and Archivist of the Holy Roman Church (1957-1971).

He was made a Cardinal Deacon in June 1936. He was consecrated a titular archbishop a year later. Six months later, per the jus optionis rules of that time, he opted to become a cardinal priest – albeit with his deaconry temporarily elevated to that of a ‘titular’ church. He, yet again using jus optionis, opted to be a cardinal bishop in February 1946. Thus, he had gone from being a cardinal deacon to a cardinal bishop is just under 10 years. He became the Sub-Dean of the College in 1948 – mainly due to Pius XII’s hesitancy to create cardinals during his near 20 year papacy.

Tisserant was atypical in sporting a beard. Unlike the current Cardinal Seán Patrick O’Malley, of Boston [USA], Tisserant was not a member of a religious order – this eliminating the assumption that he was unshaven per the precepts of his order.

Anura Guruge

  7 Responses to “Pius XII, WW II & Cardinal Tisserant — A Hitherto Undiscussed Data Point”

  1. Cardinal Tisserant was also atypical in that he privately thought the Pope’s attitude toward the Holocaust was wrong. As he wrote to Archbishop of Paris Cardinal Suhard, “our superiors do not want to understand the real nature of this conflict.” Tisserant had futilely pleaded with Pius XII to issue an encyclical clearly stating that Catholic individuals have an obligation to follow the dictates of their conscience rather than blindly executing all orders, no matter how powerful the source. He added, “I fear that history will reproach the Holy See with having practiced a policy of selfish convenience and not much else.”

    He also believed the Pope’s refusal to recognize the State of Israel was wrong. It didn’t matter to Pope Pius XII, who never recognized the Jewish state.

    Gabriel Wilensky
    Six Million Crucifixions:
    How Christian Teachings About Jews Paved the Road to the Holocaust
    Follow me on Twitter at
    Become a Fan on Facebook at

  2. Honor to hear from YOU, Gabriel.
    Congratulations on YOUR book. I know it is doing well. Better than mine. [[ SMILE ]] I guess I was wrong (again). People don’t seem to be that interested in who will be the next pope — or at least don’t want to spend ANY money to find out.
    I would LOVE an autographed copy of my book. In return I will send you one of mine. [[ SMILE ]]
    This is my email. We can exchange addresses.
    I really haven’t studied the pope’s stance on Israel. Kind of have my hands full right now trying to see if the Vatican has screwed up on the precedence of Cardinal Bishops.
    On a somewhat related topic, I just finished reading Michener’s ‘The Source’. [[Yes, I am late convert to Michener which is kind of strange as my father, a prolific author who exceeded Michener in output, was never with a Michener book in his hand.]] Gave me a LOT to think about.
    I will look up the Israel issue. I visited Israel in 1992. Wasn’t fun! Just because I am extremely sun tanned [[grin, grin]] they kept on thinking I was an ‘Arab.’
    Thanks. All the best.

  3. […] Pius XII, WW II & Cardinal Tisserant — A Hitherto Undiscussed Data … […]

  4. I got two ‘comments’ from you blog … but I think they are ‘pingbacks’ (or whatever WordPress calls them).
    I checked your blog.
    Good stuff.
    Keep checking this blog and the companion papal election specific for ongoing dialog about the popes and papacy.
    All the best. Keep up the good work.

  5. The photo in the article about Cardinal Tisserant is not Tisserant. It is Cardinal Celso Costantini (1876-1958).

  6. Interesting. I got the image, as I do most of my images, from Wikipedia Commons — and as such I realize that they could be captioned wrong.
    Here is the Wikipedia Commons link:
    I looked up Cardinal Costantini. Yes, there is a similarity.
    But these folks were well before my time.
    If you are right I can sure take down the image. No problem. I know quite a few people read this post. You are the first to point this out. So not sure what to do.

  7. The Photo is also quite similar to some photos of Cardinal Agagianian.

Rss Feed Tweeter button Facebook button Technorati button Reddit button Myspace button Linkedin button Webonews button Delicious button Digg button Stumbleupon button Newsvine button